Value
8.1/10data confidence 83%| Component | Sub-score |
|---|---|
| P/E | 8.9 |
| P/S | 9.9 |
| EV/EBITDA | 7.3 |
| Fwd P/E | 9.3 |
| PEG | 6.0 |
- ▸Forward P/E: 9.7x
- ▸PEG: 1.25
- ▸Attractively valued
DGICA · Why this verdict
Why Donegal Group (DGICA) is rated SELL
Updated
Model-generated analysis — not investment advice. Not a registered investment advisor. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Show full disclosure ▾Hide full disclosure ▴
About TrendMatrix. TrendMatrix is a publisher of general securities research and market commentary. We publish on a regular schedule. All content is the same for every subscriber in a tier — we do not provide personalized investment advice and we do not take into account any individual subscriber's financial situation, investment objectives, risk tolerance, tax situation, or holdings.
Not investment advice. TrendMatrix is not a registered investment adviser. Our content is for informational and educational purposes only. Consult your own licensed investment adviser, broker, or tax professional before making any investment decision.
Conflicts and positions. The TrendMatrix editorial team frequently holds personal long-term positions in securities discussed. We disclose positions held at the time of publication on each piece. We maintain a trading-window policy: we do not initiate or close positions in the same direction as a TrendMatrix publication within 24 hours before or 72 hours after publication.
No paid promotion. TrendMatrix does not accept payment from any issuer, broker, or third party in exchange for coverage of any security. Our sole compensation is subscription revenue.
No fiduciary duty. No fiduciary, advisory, or agency relationship is created between you and TrendMatrix by reading our content or subscribing to our service.
Performance. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Performance figures reflect the published model only and do not reflect any individual subscriber's actual results.
VerdictSELL
Overall score5.2/10
ConfidenceMEDIUM
MacroNEUTRAL
TrendMatrix Research · core thesis
Engine thesis — one sentence
Donegal Group shows notable insider buying and strong price momentum, but a quality score below the engine's exit floor, a failed negative-asymmetry gate at a reached price target, and a yield-trap dividend warning temper the setup.
Falsifiable statement — pillar-level invalidators below. Engine-derived; not personalized advice.
Thesis pillars
| Pillar | Expectation | Trend |
|---|---|---|
Quality score of 2.7 sits below the engine's 4.0 floor, driven by a weak Piotroski F-Score of 3.3 out of 9, no competitive moat, and declining revenue of -4%, triggering an exit action note. Quality breakdown | Quality score should rise above the 4.0 floor and revenue growth should turn positive over the next 12 months if underwriting results improve. | →Stable |
| CounterProperty and casualty insurers can show volatile top-line and Piotroski readings quarter to quarter due to reserve adjustments and catastrophe-loss timing, so a single period of decline may not indicate structural deterioration. | ||
Insiders showed material net buying of $3.4 million (0.477% of market cap) across 23 buy transactions with zero sells in the trailing 90 days, producing a BULLISH insider signal with high conviction and materiality scores of 8.0 each. Insider | Insider signal should remain BULLISH with continued net buying over the next 12 months. | ↑Improving |
| CounterBroad-based buying across 23 transactions with no sells could reflect a routine dividend-reinvestment or employee stock-purchase pattern common at insurers rather than a concentrated, high-conviction signal from top executives. | ||
The V9 asymmetry gate failed at -1.1 (negative), and the V8 flag shows the analyst target has effectively been reached, leaving -15.2% modeled upside. Reward-to-risk math | Asymmetry ratio should turn positive above 0 and modeled upside should turn positive over the next 12 months if new catalysts emerge beyond the current target. | →Stable |
| CounterContinued insider buying alongside a stock trading near its price target could indicate management sees additional upside the model's current target hasn't yet captured, particularly if book value continues to compound. | ||
Momentum score is strong at 6.8, driven by an overbought RSI of 82, rising on-balance volume, and price above the 200-day moving average. Momentum breakdown | Momentum score should remain elevated above 5.5 and price should hold above the 200-day moving average over the next 12 months. | Tripped↑Improving |
| CounterAn RSI of 82 is a classic overbought reading that, combined with the binary/speculative suitability flag on the industry, could precede a sharp pullback if a catastrophe-loss event or earnings miss triggers a reversal. | ||
Catalyst notes flag a yield-trap warning with a dividend safety score of 4.8, alongside a mixed earnings history of 2 beats and 2 misses over the last 4 quarters, averaging a slightly negative -3.36% surprise. Catalyst breakdown | Dividend safety score should improve above 6.0 and the earnings beat rate should improve above 50% over the next 12 months. | →Stable |
| CounterA 2-of-4 beat/miss split with a small average surprise magnitude of -3.36% is close to neutral and may not represent genuine deterioration versus normal quarter-to-quarter estimate noise for an insurer. | ||
Quality score of 2.7 sits below the engine's 4.0 floor, driven by a weak Piotroski F-Score of 3.3 out of 9, no competitive moat, and declining revenue of -4%, triggering an exit action note.
→StableQuality breakdown
- Expectation
- Quality score should rise above the 4.0 floor and revenue growth should turn positive over the next 12 months if underwriting results improve.
CounterProperty and casualty insurers can show volatile top-line and Piotroski readings quarter to quarter due to reserve adjustments and catastrophe-loss timing, so a single period of decline may not indicate structural deterioration.
Insiders showed material net buying of $3.4 million (0.477% of market cap) across 23 buy transactions with zero sells in the trailing 90 days, producing a BULLISH insider signal with high conviction and materiality scores of 8.0 each.
↑ImprovingInsider
- Expectation
- Insider signal should remain BULLISH with continued net buying over the next 12 months.
CounterBroad-based buying across 23 transactions with no sells could reflect a routine dividend-reinvestment or employee stock-purchase pattern common at insurers rather than a concentrated, high-conviction signal from top executives.
The V9 asymmetry gate failed at -1.1 (negative), and the V8 flag shows the analyst target has effectively been reached, leaving -15.2% modeled upside.
→StableReward-to-risk math
- Expectation
- Asymmetry ratio should turn positive above 0 and modeled upside should turn positive over the next 12 months if new catalysts emerge beyond the current target.
CounterContinued insider buying alongside a stock trading near its price target could indicate management sees additional upside the model's current target hasn't yet captured, particularly if book value continues to compound.
Momentum score is strong at 6.8, driven by an overbought RSI of 82, rising on-balance volume, and price above the 200-day moving average.
Tripped↑ImprovingMomentum breakdown
- Expectation
- Momentum score should remain elevated above 5.5 and price should hold above the 200-day moving average over the next 12 months.
CounterAn RSI of 82 is a classic overbought reading that, combined with the binary/speculative suitability flag on the industry, could precede a sharp pullback if a catastrophe-loss event or earnings miss triggers a reversal.
Catalyst notes flag a yield-trap warning with a dividend safety score of 4.8, alongside a mixed earnings history of 2 beats and 2 misses over the last 4 quarters, averaging a slightly negative -3.36% surprise.
→StableCatalyst breakdown
- Expectation
- Dividend safety score should improve above 6.0 and the earnings beat rate should improve above 50% over the next 12 months.
CounterA 2-of-4 beat/miss split with a small average surprise magnitude of -3.36% is close to neutral and may not represent genuine deterioration versus normal quarter-to-quarter estimate noise for an insurer.
Per-dimension breakdown
Quality
3.0/10data confidence 100%| Component | Sub-score |
|---|---|
| ROE | 3.5 |
| ROA | 1.4 |
| Gross margin | 0.0 |
| Op margin | 2.5 |
| Net margin | 3.4 |
| Current ratio | 2.0 |
| FCF quality | 5.5 |
| Moat | 4.6 |
| Piotroski F | 4.4 |
- ▸Earnings quality warning: 72% FCF/NI
- ▸No competitive moat
Growth
2.6/10data confidence 67%| Component | Sub-score |
|---|---|
| Rev growth | 1.6 |
| EPS growth | 3.6 |
- ▸Declining revenue: -4%
Momentum
3.3/10data confidence 100%| Component | Sub-score |
|---|---|
| RSI | 7.9 |
| MACD | 1.5 |
| OBV | 1.0 |
| MA position | 6.0 |
| Volume | 0.0 |
- ▸Uptrend pullback (RSI 36) - buy opportunity
- ▸Volume distribution (falling OBV)
- ▸Above 200-day MA
Sentiment
5.9/10data confidence 100%| Component | Sub-score |
|---|---|
| Analyst rating | 5.9 |
| Price target | 6.5 |
| erm sentiment | 5.0 |
- ▸Light analyst coverage (2.0) — signal dampened
Insider
8.5/10data confidence 100%| Component | Sub-score |
|---|---|
| materiality | 9.0 |
| insider conviction | 8.0 |
| holder change | 10.0 |
| notable moves | 7.0 |
- ▸Heavy insider buying — $3,408,764 (0.506% of mkt cap)
- ▸Institutions accumulating
Peer rank
4.8/10data confidence 80%| Component | Sub-score |
|---|---|
| value rank | 7.5 |
| quality rank | 2.0 |
| growth rank | 1.0 |
- ▸Conservative debt levels
Technical
7.9/10data confidence 100%| Component | Sub-score |
|---|---|
| bollinger | 7.9 |
| support resistance | 8.0 |
| 52w position | 7.7 |
Risk (lower is worse)
6.7/10data confidence 100%| Component | Sub-score |
|---|---|
| short interest | 7.6 |
| days to cover | 5.7 |
| volatility | 5.1 |
| put call | 10.0 |
| implied vol | 2.2 |
| debt equity | 9.8 |
- ▸High IV: 67%
- ▸Concentration risks: 2 MED (10-K Item 1A)
Catalyst
4.0/10data confidence 100%| Component | Sub-score |
|---|---|
| erm | 5.0 |
| earnings history | 3.3 |
| earnings timing | 5.0 |
| surprise avg | 0.8 |
| dividend safety | 5.8 |
- ▸Earnings concerns: 2B/2M
- ▸Earnings in 6 days
- ▸Dividend: 4.2%
How the verdict was assembled
Engine trigger
Quality below minimum threshold.
Engine technical detail
verdict_path:
L1:HARD_BLOCK:QUALITY_FLOORPassed (4)
- INSIDER:OK
- NEWS_EVENTS:NONE_RECENT
- SEMI_CYCLE_PEAK:CLEAR
- MATERIALS_CYCLE_PEAK:CLEAR
Failed (4)
- MOMENTUM:3.3<4.5
- ASYMMETRY:-1.0=NEGATIVE
- 8K_CRITICAL:4.01
- EARNINGS_PROXIMITY:6d<=7d
Warning (0)
none
Reward-to-Risk
-1.00
Upside
-5.9%
Downside
5.9%
Sizing output
AVOID
Setup— — No clear chart pattern; technical signals are mixed
EdgeInst Constrain — Small cap ($0.7B) below institutional reach
SuitabilitySpeculative — Binary industry: Insurance - Property & Casualty
Investment implication
The SELL_IF_HOLDING verdict reflects the MOMENTUM gate's 3.3<4.5 outcome against Insider at 8.5 and asymmetric R:R of -1.00.
The strongest dimensions are Insider at 8.5, Value at 8.1, and Technical at 7.9; the weakest are Growth at 2.6, Quality at 3.0, and Momentum at 3.3. The V9 engine flagged 4 failed gates, producing an asymmetric reward-to-risk of -1.00 and an engine sizing output of AVOID.
What would invalidate the thesis
Falsifying conditions — when triggered, the corresponding pillar's thesis is invalidated.
- P1Notable Insider Buying Signal
Trip ifNet insider value over 90 days turns negative, falling below $0 (from the current +$3.4 million), or C-level sell value exceeds $500,000.
- P2Quality Below Floor Declining Revenue
Trip ifQuality score rises above 4.0 (from the current 2.7), or revenue growth turns positive (from -4%).
- P3Negative Asymmetry Target Reached
Trip ifAsymmetry ratio rises above 0.5 (from the current -1.1), or modeled upside turns positive, exceeding 5%.
- P4Overbought Momentum Above 200maTripped
Trip ifRSI falls below 50 (from the current overbought 82 reading) or price closes below its 200-day moving average.
- P5Yield Trap Mixed Earnings History
Trip ifDividend safety score rises above 6.0 (from the current 4.8), or earnings beat rate rises to 3 of the next 4 quarters.